It's Okay to Ask: How to Get a Second Opinion in Neurology

It's Okay to Ask: How to Get a Second Opinion in Neurology

If you’ve been told you have a neurological condition, or worse, that your symptoms are "all in your head," it’s normal to feel overwhelmed or unsure of what to do next. You might worry about doubting your health care provider, or just feel exhausted from the endless cycle of appointments when all you want are real answers, not more uncertainty.

Getting a second opinion in neurology ensures that you receive the correct diagnosis and treatment, especially since these conditions can be challenging to accurately identify. The brain and nervous system are complex, and even top neurologists can view things differently or overlook small details.

Why second opinions matter in neurology

Neurological conditions are especially tricky to diagnose.

Migraine attacks can mimic seizures. Parkinson's can be confused with essential tremor. Even with advanced imaging and tests, diagnosis often relies on clinical judgment, and two equally qualified neurologists might reach different conclusions.

The stakes are high. If a diagnosis is missed or wrong, it can lead to years of frustration, treatments that don’t work, worsening symptoms, worsening stress, or missing out on something that could really help. Studies show that second opinions in neurology change the diagnosis, treatment, or prognosis in 10 % to 62 % of cases.

Certain situations especially warrant a second opinion:

  • You've been diagnosed with a rare or serious condition
  • Surgery or other invasive treatments are recommended
  • Your symptoms don't match your diagnosis
  • Treatment isn't working after reasonable trial periods
  • You're told "nothing can be done"
  • Your concerns are dismissed without a proper investigation

Common diagnostic challenges

Some neurological conditions are often misdiagnosed. Epilepsy and psychogenic seizures need different treatments, but they can look the same. MS lesions might be confused with migraine-associated changes on an MRI. Migraine subtypes are often misidentified. Functional neurological disorder is real and has real symptoms, but providers sometimes diagnose it too quickly when they can’t find another cause.

Women and people of color often face extra challenges, and their symptoms are more likely to be ignored or blamed on anxiety. If you’ve ever felt dismissed or rushed at the clinic, getting a second opinion can help you feel listened to and get the careful evaluation you deserve.

When to seek another opinion

If something feels off about your diagnosis or treatment plan, that's reason enough. But especially consider a second opinion if:

  • Your diagnosis was made very quickly without thorough testing
  • You have a progressive condition, but aren't seeing a subspecialist
  • Major life decisions (career, family planning) depend on your prognosis
  • You're experiencing new symptoms that don't fit your diagnosis
  • Your provider seems unfamiliar with your condition

How to get a second opinion

Don't worry about offending your current neurologist.

Most health care providers understand that obtaining a second opinion is a common practice, especially for complex medical conditions. You can just say, "I'd like to get a second opinion to be thorough." You don’t need to give a long explanation.

Ask for copies of your medical records, scans, and test results. Having these ready helps avoid repeat tests and provides the new neurologist with all the necessary details. If you can, look for a provider who specializes in your condition, like a memory specialist, sleep specialist, epileptologist, headache specialist, stroke specialist, etc.

Consider major medical centers or academic hospitals, which often have subspecialists and access to newer diagnostic tools. Alternatively, you can opt for Neura Health for virtual consultations with subspecialists. We can review your history, address your concerns, evaluate, and examine your records and imaging without requiring travel.

When opinions differ

If the second opinion confirms your initial diagnosis, you can proceed with greater confidence. But if the providers disagree, don’t worry. This happens often in neurology. Think about the following:

  • Which explanation better fits all your symptoms?
  • Which provider took more time and was more thorough?
  • Is a third opinion from a subspecialist warranted?
  • Can your providers discuss your case together?

Sometimes, the answer lies in monitoring over time, as certain conditions become clearer as they progress.

The value of self-advocacy

Seeking clear answers about a serious diagnosis is a responsible and caring approach to your health.

Even the best health care providers don’t know everything, and medicine is constantly evolving, especially in the field of neurology. Every specialist has their own experience and insight, and you deserve to benefit from that. Your situation is unique, so getting more opinions can help you feel more supported.

If you have doubts, unexplained symptoms, or big treatment decisions ahead, getting a second opinion is both reasonable and smart. Neura Health is one of the quickest ways to get a second opinion. Book a visit with one of our neurology subspecialists today and see them within days.

For more great content, follow us:
Instagram IconFacebook Icon
Brooke Masilak
Brooke is a board-certified nurse practitioner with an added qualification in headache medicine from the National Headache Foundation.
About the Author
Brooke Masilak has extensive experience in many areas of neurology, including headache medicine, concussion/TBI, post-covid neurological symptoms, stroke recovery, tremor and more. She obtained her Masters of Science in Nursing from Long Island University, Bachelor of Science in Nursing from Baptist Memorial College of Health Sciences, and Bachelor of Science in Psychology from the University of Georgia. As part of her clinical training, she completed a clinical rotation with the Department of Integrative Medicine at Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center where she also worked as an RN in neurology for several years. She received her Family Practice Nurse Practitioner board certification from the American Academy of Nurse Practitioners. Additionally, Brooke maintains a certification for Added Qualification in Headache Medicine (AQH) from the National Headache Foundation. Brooke has trained under a physician who is double board certified in headache medicine and neurology. She is committed to helping patients optimize their health and wellbeing from a holistic perspective.

Share this article

Looking for expert neurology care?

Video visits within days

Talk with neurologists

Get Rx delivered

Learn More

Finally, expert neurology care at your fingertips

Neura Health is a comprehensive virtual neurology clinic. Meet with a neurology specialist via video appointment, and get treatment from home.

Phone and Leaf Mockup